The Existential Moment typographic logo

The Existential Moment: Why “Resistance” Matters—The Existential Cost and the Therapeutic Aim

Seeing a line of windmills as ominous giants, Don Quixote lowers his lance and charges, unable to sense that the world long passed him by. Living in an age of commerce and gunpowder, that of 17th-century Spain, he remains faithful to a medieval, chivalric order that had faded into legend centuries earlier. What appears as resistance to reality is, in fact, fidelity to a map of meaning shaped by an earlier time. 

In psychotherapy, “resistance” and “defenses” are often understood as an obstacle, something the client does that impedes progress or blocks change. From an existential-humanistic perspective, however, the deeper concern is not resistance itself but the ways in which entrenched patterns of self-protection quietly shape a person’s way of living. 

When protective patterns become rigid and unexamined, they can narrow a person’s capacity for presence and possibility. Life is increasingly organized through familiar meanings and behaviors rather than lived immediacy and authentic choice. Contact with primary experience, such as felt emotion, embodied sensation, gives way to habitual stances that promise safety but limit vitality. These patterns often persist long after the conditions that required them have passed, operating automatically and outside awareness. 

The cost of this constriction is not merely clinical stagnation; it is existential. Choice becomes constrained. Emotional and relational life is diminished. Intimacy, creativity, agency, and meaning are often diminished when a way of being no longer allows full participation in life as it unfolds. 

Consequently, the aim of E-H therapy is not to “overcome” resistance, but to transform the person’s relationship to it. The work seeks to restore awareness, expand presence, and reopen choice within real limits, allowing individuals to encounter how they are presently living—and how they may now be willing to live.

Related Blog Posts:

Read other Existential Moment posts on Existential-Humanistic practice.

Explore protections and protective patterns in E-H therapy in previous posts. 

Read more about working with resistance in the therapeutic relationship.

View all the Existential Moment series posts on EHI’s blog.

Existential Moment Author: Scott Gibbs, LMFT, EHI Board Member-at-Large | Website: www.mscottgibbs.com | Twitter: @Novum_Organum

Share this post

Related Posts:

The Existential Moment typographic logo

The Existential Moment: E-H Informed Couples Therapy —The Relational Field

Earlier this year, The Existential Moment began exploring an E-H-informed approach to couples therapy. After sketching the framework (May) and considering distress and health (June), this month turns to a theory of relational organization: how two distinct “ways of being” meet to construct and sustain a shared “world.” This frame offers the clinician an orienting touchstone so that distress can be understood and change can be facilitated more intentionally.

Within E-H’s “Dimensions of the Therapeutic Encounter,” the interpersonal dimension provides a useful parallel. It directs attention toward the therapist-client relationship as it is being lived in the here-and-now. How do we affect one another? What’s the quality of the “between” us? What ways of being emerge within the relationship? In couples work, this relational process becomes the basis for understanding how two lived lives come together and begin to influence and organize one another.

Read More »
The Existential Moment typographic logo

Author of The Existential Moment is Doing a Workshop!

The creator of EHI’s The Existential Moment blog series, Scott Gibbs, is facilitating an online Lunch-n-Learn on September 11th where he will be discussing the topic of his new book, Toward the Turning: Rethinking the Meaning of 9/11, the Clash of Civilizations, and a Postmodern World. This event is being hosted online by our friends at Existential-Humanistic NorthWest in Portland, Oregon. 

Read More »
  • Search EHI's Blog

    Ongoing series on Existential & Humanistic therapy

    Get Updates

    Join our mailing list and get the latest in news and events.

    Blog Archives